Impact damage to chickpea seeds during free fall
More details
Hide details
Department of Biosystems Engineering, Lorestan University, Khorramabad, 6815144316, Iran
Department of Agriculture and Plant Breeding, Lorestan University, Khorramabad, 6815144316, Iran
Feizollah Shahbazi   

Farm machinery, Lorestan University, Iran
Final revision date: 2022-10-06
Acceptance date: 2022-10-25
Publication date: 2023-01-27
Int. Agrophys. 2023, 37(1): 41–49
  • In most cases, higher damage resulted when seeds were dropped on concrete than on the metal surface.
  • Drop height was a significant factor causing damage to chickpea seeds.
  • On striking a surface at speeds of above 8 m/s, the percentage breakage of chickpea seeds was at least 10.28 %.
  • To reduce damage to seeds due to the impact caused by free fall, the drop height should be limited to about 5 m.
The study aimed to determine the extent of the percentage of mechanical damage (seed breakage) to chickpea seeds due to the impact caused by free fall. Three independent variables were used in the test, namely: impact surface (concrete, metal, plywood and seed-on-seed), drop height (3, 6, 9, and 12 m) and seed moisture content (10, 15, 20, and 25% w.b.). The results showed that all three independent variables significantly influenced the percentage breakage of chickpea seeds. The seeds dropped onto concrete and metal had by a significant margin the highest means of percentage breakage at 13.89 and 12.94%, respectively, in comparison with 10.64 and 8.34% on plywood and in the case of seed to seed impact, respectively. Increasing the drop height from 3 to 12 m caused a significant increase in the mean values of damage to seeds from 7.20 to 15.57%. Increasing the moisture levels caused a decreasing trend by a factor of two in the damage to the seeds due to free fall. Empirical models were developed to reveal the relationships between damage to chickpea seeds with various moisture contents that was due to the impact with different impact surfaces caused by free fall from the drop height.
The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest. Furthermore, the manuscript does not contain experiments using animals or humans.
ASABE Standards, 2006. S352. 2 Moisture measurement – Unground Grain and Seeds. American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers, Michigan, St. Joseph.
ASABE Standards, 2008. S368.3: Compression test of food materials of convex shape. American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers, Michigan, St. Joseph.
Asiedu E.A., 1986. Influence of delayed harvest, chilling and mechanical injury on quality of stored seed corn (Zea mays L.) (No. CIMMYT.). M.S. Thesis, Mississippi State University, Mississippi State.
Bergen G.A., Jayas D.S., and White N.D.G., 1993. Physical damage to peas and lentils due to free fall. Can. Agric. Eng., 35(2),151-155.
Bilanski W.K., 1966. Damage resistance of seed grains. Trans. ASABE, 9, 360-0363,
Chen Z., Wassgren C., and Ambrose K., 2020. A review of grain kernel damage: mechanisms, modeling, and testing procedures. Trans. ASABE, 63, 455-475,
Chen Z., Wassgren C., and Ambrose R.K., 2021. Measured damage resistance of corn and wheat kernels to compression, friction, and repeated impacts. Powder Technol., 380, 638-648,
DaSilva A.B.P., Scatolini T.B., Danao M.G.C., Gates R.S., and Rausch K.D., 2018. Effects of splits content on dry matter loss rates of soybeans measured using a static grain respiration measurement system. Proc. ASABE Annual Int. Meeting, July 9-12, Portland, OR, USA.
Delfan F., 2020. Investigation of mechanical damage to chickpea seeds due to free fall using electrical conductivity tests accelerated aging and storage capacity changes (in Farsi). M.S. Thesis, Faculty of Agriculture. Lorestan University, Khorram Abad, Iran.
Deng T., Garg V., Salehi H., and Bradley M.S., 2021. Correlations between segregation intensity and material properties such as particle sizes and adhesions and novel methods for assessment. Powder Technol., 387, 215-226,
Evans M.D., Homes R.G., and McDonald M.B., 1990. Impact damage to soybean seed as affected by surface hardness and seed orientation. Trans. ASABE, 33(1), 234-240,
Fan Y., Jacob K.V., Freireich B., and Lueptow R.M., 2017. Segregation of granular materials in bounded heap flow: A review. Powder Technol., 312, 67-88,
Fiscus D.E., Foster G.H., and Kaufmami H.H., 1971. Physical damage of grain caused by various handling techniques. Trans. ASABE., 14(3), 480-0485,
Foster G.H. and Holman L.E., 1973. Grain breakage caused by commercial handling methods. Marketing Research Report No. 968. Washington, DC: USDA-ARS. Retrieved from
Frączek J. and Ślipek Z., 1998. Influence of moisture content and number of loading of mechanical impacts, upon the energy and sprouting capacity of wheat grains. Int. Agrophys., 12(2), 97‐101.
Gatongi I.N., 1982. Effects of mechanical injury upon corn (Zea mays L.) seed quality. M.S. Thesis, Mississippi State University. Mississippi State.
Gregg B. and Billups G., 2016. Seed Conditioning, Volume 2: Technology-Parts A & B. CRC Press,
Gu R.L., Huang R., JIA G.Y., Yuan Z.P., Ren L.S., Li L., and Wang J.H., 2019. Effect of mechanical threshing on damage and vigor of maize seed threshed at different moisture contents. J. Integr. Agric., 18(7), 1571-1578,
Guo D., 2015. Kernel and bulk density changes due to moisture content, mechanical damage, and insect damage (Doctoral dissertation), Purdue University.
Jan K.N., Panesar P.S., and Singh S., 2019. Effect of moisture content on the physical and mechanical properties of quinoa seeds. Int. Agrophys., 33(1), 41-48,
Khazaei J., Shahbazi F., Massah J., Nikravesh M., and Kianmehr M.H., 2008. Evaluation and modeling of physical and physiological damage to wheat seeds under successive impact loadings: mathematical and neural networks modeling. Crop Sci., 48, 1532-1544,
Li X., Ma F., and Gao L., 2009. Dropping impact experiment on corn seeds. Trans. Chin Soci. Agri. Eng., 25(1), 113-116.
Liu S., Song F., Liu F., Zhu X., and Xu H., 2012. Effect of planting density on root lodging resistance and its relationship to nodal root growth characteristics in maize (Zea mays L.). J. Agric. Sci., 4(12), 182-189,
Meyers T.P. and Hollinger S.E., 2004. An assessment of storage terms in the surface energy balance of maize and soybean. Agric. For. Meteorol., 125(1-2), 105-115,
Mir H. and Shahbazi F., 2022. Simulated transit vibration effects on the postharvest quality of persimmon during storage. Postharvest Biol. Technol., 189, 111918,
Mohsenin N.N., 1986. Physical properties of plant and animal materials. New York, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers.
Narendran RB., Jian F., Jayas D.S., Fields P.G., and White N.D., 2019. Segregation of canola, kidney bean, and soybean in wheat bulks during bin loading. Powder Technol., 344, 307-313,
Paulsen M.R., Nave W.R., and Gray L.E., 1981. Soybean seed quality as affected by the impact damage. Trans. ASABE 24(6),1577-1582,
Paulsen M.R., Singh M., and Singh V., 2019. Measurement and maintenance of corn quality. In: Corn (Ed. S.O. Serna-Saldivar). 165-211. AACC International Press,
Perry J.S. and Hall C.W., 1966. Evaluating and reducing mechanical-handling damage to pea beans. Trans. ASABE, 9(5), 696-0701,
Shah F.S., Watson C.E., Meredith N.D., Bohn P.A., and Marti B., 2001. Effect of bean ladder usage on mechanical damage during soybean seed conditioning. Seed Technol., 23, 92-97.
Shahbazi F., 2011. Impact damage to chickpea seeds as affected by moisture content and impact velocity. Appl. Eng. Agric., 27(5), 771-775,
Shahbazi F., 2012. A study on the seed susceptibility of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivars to impact damage. J. Agric. Sci. Technol., 14(3), 505-512.
Shahbazi F., 2021. Mechanical damage to agricultural grains (Causes and solutions) (in Farsi). Lorestan University Press, Khorram Abad, Iran.
Shahbazi F., Saffar A., and Analooei M., 2011a. Mechanical damage to pinto beans as affected by moisture content and impact energy. Agric. Eng. Int.: CIGR J., 13(2), Manuscript No.1867.
Shahbazi F., Saffar A., and Analooei M., 2011b. Mechanical damage to navy beans as affected by moisture content, impact velocity and seed orientation. Qual. Assur. Saf., 3, 205-211,
Shahbazi F., Valizadeh S., and Dolatshaie A., 2011c. Correlating the data on the mechanical damage to mung bean seeds under impact loading. Int. J. Food Eng., 7(6), Article 10,
Shahbazi F., Sharafi R., Moomevandi S.J., and Daneshvar M., 2015a. Influence of foliar iron fertilization rate on the breakage susceptibility of wheat seeds. J. Plant Nutr., 38(14), 2204-2216,
Shahbazi F., Sharafi R., Moomevandi S.J., and Daneshvar M., 2015b. Mechanical damage to wheat seeds as affected by phosphorus and iron fertilization rate. Qual. Assur. Saf., 7(3), 385-391,
Shahbazi F., Valizadeh S., and Dowlatshah A., 2012. Mechanical damage to wheat and triticale seeds related to moisture content and impact energy. Agric. Eng. Int.: CIGR J., 14(4), 150-155.
Shahbazi F., Valizade S., and Dowlatshah A., 2017. Mechanical damage to green and red lentil seeds. Food Sci. Nutr., 5(4), 943-947,
Shahbazi F. and Shahbazi R., 2019. Mechanical damage to corn seeds. Cercetari Agronomice in Moldova, 51(3), 1-12,
Shahbazi R. and Shahbazi F., 2022a. Effects of cushion box and closed let-down ladder usage on mechanical damage during corn kernel handling: Cracking. J. Stored Prod. Res., 99, 102006,
Shahbazi R. and Shahbazi F., 2022b. Effects of cushion box and closed let-down ladder usage on mechanical damage during corn kernel handling: Cracking. Food Sci. Nutr., 00, 1-11,
Shahbazi R. and Shahbazi F., 2022c. Effects of cushion box and closed let-down ladder usage on mechanical damage during corn kernel handling: Cracking. Plant Methods, 18(142), 1-11,
Sosnowski S., and Kuźniar P., 1999. Effect of dynamic loading on the quality of soybean. Int. Agrophys., 13(1), 125‐132.
Srivastava A.K., Herum F.L., and Stevens K.K., 1976. Impact parameters related to physical damage to corn kernel. Trans. ASABE, 19(6), 1147-1151,
Su Y., Cui T., Zhang D., Xia G., Gao X., He X., and Xu Y., 2019a. MLR and experimental testing for characterization and classification of damage resistance of maize hybrids based on mechanical properties. J. Food Process Eng., 42(7), e13262,
Su Y., Cui T., Zhang D., Xia G., Gao X., He X., and Xu Y., 2019b. Damage resistance and compressive properties of bulk maize kernels at varying pressing factors: Experiments and modeling. J. Food Process Eng., 42(7), e13267,
Su Y., Cui T., Zhang D., Xia G., Gao X., He X., and XuY., 2020. Effects of shape feature on compression characteristics and crack rules of maize kernel. J. Food Process. Preserv., 44(1), e14307,
Szwed G. and Łukaszuk J., 2007. Effect of rapeseed and wheat kernel moisture on impact damage. Int. Agrophys., 21(3), 299‐304.